Telehealth Mental Health Parity Laws: What Benefit Brokers Need to Know
Written by
Phoenix Health Editorial Team
Expert health information, double-checked for accuracy and written to be helpful.
Last updated
Why Telehealth Parity Is Central to Perinatal Mental Health Access
Telehealth delivery is not a convenience feature for postpartum patients -- it is often the only practicable way to access regular mental health care during the first year post-delivery. New parents face transportation constraints, childcare barriers, and physical recovery factors that make weekly in-person appointments unrealistic for a significant fraction of the population.
A perinatal mental health benefit that covers in-person behavioral health but does not cover telehealth at parity is functionally restricted for the population it purports to serve. For benefit brokers, this means that plan design review needs to include a specific telehealth parity analysis, not just a general behavioral health parity review.
---
The Federal Telehealth Framework
MHPAEA and telehealth
The Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act (MHPAEA) and its 2023 Final Rule require that mental health and substance use disorder benefits be provided on terms no more restrictive than medical/surgical benefits. If a plan covers telehealth medical visits, it must cover telehealth mental health visits on comparable terms.
The parity analysis requires looking at:
- Coverage parity: Is telehealth mental health covered at all, when telehealth medical visits are covered?
- Cost-sharing parity: Is the co-pay or coinsurance for telehealth mental health equivalent to telehealth medical services?
- Prior authorization parity: Are prior authorization requirements for telehealth mental health more burdensome than for telehealth medical services?
- Network adequacy: Does the plan's telehealth behavioral health network provide comparable access to the telehealth medical network?
Each of these is a potential parity issue. The 2023 MHPAEA Final Rule's NQTL comparative analysis requirements mean plan sponsors must document compliance, not just assert it.
Consolidated Appropriations Act telehealth extensions
The Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021 (CAA 2021) and subsequent legislation extended COVID-era telehealth flexibilities. For Medicare-covered services, telehealth behavioral health coverage has been extended with requirements broadly comparable to in-person coverage.
For commercial plans, the federal baseline is set by MHPAEA parity requirements and the ACA's preventive services mandate (which covers PMAD screening without cost-sharing for non-grandfathered plans). Specific telehealth coverage rules for commercial plans are primarily state-governed.
---
State Telehealth Parity Law Landscape
As of 2024, 43 states plus the District of Columbia have enacted telehealth parity laws. The scope and requirements vary significantly.
Coverage parity vs. payment parity
This is the most important distinction for plan design purposes.
Coverage parity requires that if an in-person service is covered, the telehealth equivalent must also be covered. All state telehealth parity laws provide at least coverage parity.
Payment parity requires that the reimbursement rate for a telehealth service equal the reimbursement rate for the in-person equivalent. Approximately 30 states require payment parity; others require only coverage parity, permitting lower reimbursement for telehealth delivery.
Why this matters for perinatal mental health: Lower telehealth reimbursement rates reduce provider participation in telehealth networks. PMH-C-certified perinatal therapists who can choose between in-person and telehealth patients will make practice decisions based on reimbursement. States without payment parity may have lower telehealth specialist availability than states with full parity requirements.
Audio-only coverage
A significant coverage variation across states is whether audio-only (telephone) telehealth visits are covered alongside audio-video visits.
Audio-only telehealth is clinically relevant for perinatal mental health: some patients in early postpartum recovery lack reliable broadband access or have situations where video participation is difficult (infant in the room, privacy constraints). Audio-only therapy is less effective than video for most presentations but is significantly better than no contact.
State coverage of audio-only behavioral health telehealth varies widely. Some states require coverage equivalent to audio-video; others limit parity requirements to audio-video technology only.
Provider type coverage
Some state parity laws are specific to physician telehealth services and may not explicitly extend to licensed clinical social workers (LCSWs), licensed professional counselors (LPCs), or licensed marriage and family therapists (LMFTs) -- the provider types who deliver most outpatient behavioral health care.
Confirm that your client's plan telehealth parity coverage explicitly includes LCSWs and LPCs, not just physicians and psychologists. Most perinatal mental health therapists are licensed clinical social workers or licensed counselors, not psychologists.
---
Practical Broker Checklist for Telehealth Parity Review
When reviewing a client's plan for telehealth mental health parity compliance:
Coverage analysis:
- [ ] Are telehealth behavioral health services covered in all states where employees are located?
- [ ] Is coverage equivalent to in-person behavioral health coverage (same benefit limits, same diagnoses covered)?
- [ ] Is audio-only behavioral health telehealth covered in states that require it?
Cost-sharing analysis:
- [ ] Is the telehealth behavioral health co-pay equivalent to the in-person behavioral health co-pay?
- [ ] Is the telehealth behavioral health deductible structure equivalent to the in-person structure?
- [ ] Is telehealth behavioral health treated equivalently to telehealth medical services?
Prior authorization analysis:
- [ ] Does the plan require prior authorization for telehealth behavioral health?
- [ ] If so, is the prior authorization requirement equivalent to what applies to telehealth medical services?
- [ ] Is the prior authorization approval timeline comparable for telehealth behavioral health vs. telehealth medical?
Network adequacy:
- [ ] Does the telehealth behavioral health network include PMH-C-certified providers?
- [ ] Does the network cover all states where employees are located?
- [ ] What is the time-to-appointment for a new telehealth behavioral health patient in the client's primary states?
---
PSYPACT and Multi-State Licensure
A practical complication for perinatal mental health telehealth is that therapist licensure is state-based. A therapist in California cannot provide telehealth services to a patient in Texas without Texas licensure (or a PSYPACT exception for psychologists).
PSYPACT (Psychology Interjurisdictional Compact) allows psychologists to provide telehealth services across member states with a single authorization. As of 2024, PSYPACT has approximately 40 member states.
PSYPACT does not apply to LCSWs, LPCs, or LMFTs. These providers require individual licensure in each state where they provide telehealth services. For multi-state employers, this means specialty perinatal mental health access depends on the specific provider's state licensure portfolio.
When evaluating specialty perinatal mental health vendors for multi-state employer clients, confirm:
- How many states does the vendor's therapist network cover?
- Does the vendor have providers licensed in [specific states where the client has material employee populations]?
- What is the vendor's process for licensing expansion if they do not currently cover all relevant states?
---
Trends to Watch
Federal telehealth permanence: Federal telehealth flexibilities have been repeatedly extended since COVID-era implementation. Legislative proposals to make many of these flexibilities permanent are active. The direction of federal policy is toward greater telehealth access, not less.
Medicaid telehealth: CMS has been moving toward permanent telehealth parity in Medicaid following the COVID extensions. States that implemented expanded telehealth coverage under the public health emergency have largely maintained it.
MHPAEA enforcement: The 2023 MHPAEA Final Rule's enforcement timeline is rolling out through 2025 and 2026. Self-insured plan sponsors and carriers who have not completed NQTL comparative analyses face increasing compliance risk, particularly as state insurance departments and the DOL increase audit activity.
---
For a full guide to adding perinatal mental health to your broker portfolio, see our article on the benefit broker guide to perinatal mental health.
For a broader review of MHPAEA parity requirements as they apply to perinatal mental health specifically, see our article on insurance coverage and telehealth parity for perinatal mental health.
Frequently Asked Questions
MHPAEA is a federal law requiring that mental health benefits be no more restrictive than analogous medical benefits. It does not directly mandate telehealth coverage but does require that if a plan covers telehealth for medical services, it cannot impose more restrictive conditions on telehealth for mental health. State telehealth parity laws go further: over 40 states now have explicit laws requiring payers to reimburse telehealth mental health services at the same rate and under the same conditions as in-person care. For employer groups with multi-state workforces, the state law governing the insurance contract (typically the employer's domicile state) applies to fully insured plans. Self-insured ERISA plans are exempt from state law and governed by federal standards only.
The key evaluation criteria are: (1) whether telehealth mental health is covered at parity with in-person (same cost-sharing, no separate deductible); (2) whether the in-network telehealth provider panel includes perinatal-specialized therapists, not just general EAP counselors; (3) what session limits apply and whether they are equitable with in-person limits; (4) whether audio-only sessions are covered (critical for postpartum patients with infants who cannot manage video visits); and (5) what the actual time-to-appointment standard is. Plans that lead with "telehealth included" as a marketing differentiator but have 3-to-4-week waits for a first appointment are offering a nominal benefit.
For self-insured clients, the benefit design is fully negotiable at renewal and the broker has direct influence. The practical levers are: specifying telehealth parity as a plan design requirement in the plan document, requiring the TPA or stop-loss carrier to apply state-equivalent telehealth standards, selecting a specialty perinatal mental health vendor (such as a telehealth-first practice) as a point-solution benefit rather than relying on the general EAP or carrier network, and benchmarking against what comparable self-insured employers in the same industry offer. The ROI argument for perinatal telehealth access is strong: untreated PPD costs employers an estimated $32,000 per affected employee in productivity, turnover, and healthcare utilization.
Ready to take the next step?
Our PMH-C certified therapists specialize in exactly this — and most clients are seen within a week.